6
neeno
42d

# !dev (?) Why does my teacher think it's reasonable to give an assignment for writing a scientific article about quantum computing in the first semester of CS? Like really? I just got out of fucking high school you bitch, all math I know is basic linear algebra. Thankfully I'm a nerd that likes computers so I got the basis of classical computing covered, I can only imagine how my classmates that never touched a computer are holding up.

• 1
It's not that I don't like the subject, in fact I'm loving it and thinking of specializing in quantum computing one day, but don't you think this is a bit much for a first semester assignment?
• 4
Probably to scare everyone off the course who thinks it's going to be about writing println statements, using Excel macros, or just people that think they know it all already.
• 3
Interesting enough, one of the most basic mathematical concepts you need to understand to get into quantum computing is linear algebra :D you have the advantage!
• 2
@AleCx04 yeah, at least that, but I don't understand 80% of this math because I don't have all the other knowledge required. Dirac's notation, what the hell is a Hilbert space, stuff like that. Little by little I'm learning (and actually understanding \o/) what these are. Then there are quantum mechanics concepts like superposition, entanglement, etc. I get the very basic concept of those but it's hard to find resources explaining it in a way that makes sense and says more than "superposition means a qubit can be 0 and 1 at the same time" without requiring all this math and physics knowledge. Plus learing it all in a month is a bit tight....
• 2
TBF, it's not quantum physics. Oh wait... At least it's not rocket science.
• 2
Depending on the situation, I'd fire that man in the spot. idk about you, but teachers are supposed to teach stuff instead of saying "oh yeah, self-studying lecture, complete exercises 4.012 through 5.001, can't be bothered to answer your questions either."
• 1
@PublicByte yeah... My teacher is crazy, everyone says that. But I think she gave us this assignment to see how well we know how to research and write an article (it's a scientific writing class), so maybe she won't be expecting too much from us.

Anyways, I think I figured out how to do this. So far I understand pretty decently how qubits work so I think I'll write my article about qubits. That's all. Idk anything about quantum error correction, how the fuck these algorithms work and the math behind all quantum gates. I know the basics of qubits, so I'll write about that, make a decent article about one thing is better then a half-assed one about a dozen things.
• 2
Depends on the level of detail required.

getting a very loose general idea of the possibilities of quantum computing is not that insane.

Even non-programmers can get the gist of just how hufe the jump quantum computing would be, plus some of the challenges invovled, after reading 15 minutes of wikipedia.

I think it’s a solid idea to make students read a bit about it just to know SOMETHING about it.

(Even if it’s not practically viable at the moment. As a comparison: it was good to know how ray-tracing would work even long before it was practically usable in games)
• 0

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...

https://futurism.com/scientists-hav...

Someplace there is a picture of the chemical makeup of the material from a Superman movie still, where it was a stand-in for Kryptonite..

Now, I wish I could find that picture again !

Obviously, if anyone is writing a picture search engine, bet it can't find that !
• 0
@Nanos

-----

Herbertsmithite, in a pure synthetic form, was discovered in 2012 to be able to exhibit the properties of a quantum spin liquid, a generalized form of strongly correlated quantum spin liquid [3] due to its Kagome lattice structure.[4] Herbertsmithite is the first mineral known to exhibit this unique state of magnetism: it is neither a ferromagnet with mostly aligned magnetic particles, nor is it an antiferromagnet with mostly opposed adjacent magnetic particles; rather its magnetic particles have constantly fluctuating scattered orientations.

Optical conductivity observations[5] suggest the magnetic state in herbertsmithite is a type of emergent gauge field of a gapless U(1) Dirac spin liquid. Other experiments [6][7][8] and some numerical calculations suggest instead that it is a Z 2 {\displaystyle \mathbb {Z} _{2}} \mathbb {Z} _{2} spin liquid (or in other words, has a Z 2 {\displaystyle \mathbb {Z} _{2}} \mathbb {Z} _{2} topological order).

-----