31
SnuKies
3y

I wrote in a rant here that I couldn't access my 1TB external hard-drive anymore because I refused to "Safely remove" it from my computer.

My brother sent me today an image with it, showing me that he managed to open it.

I can't tell you how happy I am!

The solution: if you encounter the same problem (it takes forever for windows to scan it and you can't open it/ on linux it tells you to go to windows and and properly eject it), just go to `Device Manager` and `Scan for new hardware`. This should find it & solve it

Comments
  • 5
    i don't think linux ever asked me to do so
    I sometimes forget to safely remove my 2TB hdd, it works fine on linux(ubuntu)
  • 10
    Life is too short to remove devices safely
  • 1
    @chowdercake
    Nope. If you leave an NTFS partition in an "unsafe" state it will complain. In particular ntfs-3g will tell you that it can't handle with partitions in such a state. Since Windows 8 it no longer properly shuts down the US which can cause the same thing as well.

    I think that there is a check disk utility for Linux that can fix the filesystem.
  • 0
    @Zennoe i think from windows 8, the safe to remove hardware feature was abandoned

    cause the buffer which is used to transfer data was cleared automatically
    PS: I don't know for sure but read it somewhere and i either use & or work on server editions
  • 0
    @chowdercake write cache is disabled for external USB drives. But I presume you can still leave NTFS in a state that ntfs-3g cannot cope with. It's partially reverse engineered so it is not a big surprise that it is a less stable implementation than what comes with Windows.
Add Comment