Ranter
Join devRant
Do all the things like
++ or -- rants, post your own rants, comment on others' rants and build your customized dev avatar
Sign Up
Pipeless API
From the creators of devRant, Pipeless lets you power real-time personalized recommendations and activity feeds using a simple API
Learn More
Comments
-
I am not security expert and definitely not on vpns but how is that possible? Can someone explain?
-
Sounds like a bad VPN that doesn't provide custom DNS servers.
It's impossible to geo-ban an app completely. -
@lamka02sk
If you control the literal border routers you can control access to known vpn endpoint addresses, sort of. That said, there's very easy ways to wrap your traffic in traffic that won't send up red flags, so it's pretty simple to bypass, even in China. -
@SortOfTested umm.. You mean like double encryption? I.E. Client-border router and router-vpn in south amer? Wouldn't that require tremendous amounts of resources [encryption + filtering + encryption]?
Otherwise I don't see how could it be possible to mitm+filter encrypted vpn traffic
my guess would be dns-level ban :) not all vpns suggest their dns settings -
@theKarlisK depends on what you mean by 'protection' :)
i mean you can set up your routing table to hide all the traffic, including dns queries, assuming you're using a 3rd-party dns, not your isp's. Not fucking your routing table automatically is not lack of protection - it's not fucking things up and leaving that part for the client :) frankly I do prefer this kind of vpn clients [looking at you, anyconnect, you mfucker!] -
I mean I hate governments blocking apps or websites as much as anyone, but this is TikTok...
-
@PrivateGER usually they block custom dns servers too, it a game of cat and mouse
even during nation wide porn ban they did the same thing -
@hardfault China tries to block stuff for years and is still failing. I doubt India can do better.
-
@PrivateGER there is no logical reasoning in that statement, it’s seems like your personal opinion
-
@hardfault Yes there is. China has been working hard on their Great Firewall for years now, but you just cannot block VPN servers because it takes less than 10 seconds to simply spin up a new one on some random server and serving the VPN over port 443, making it undetectable for anything but Deep Packet Inspection. Blocking web services is a losing battle unless you just disconnect the whole thing.
-
@PrivateGER yes but 120 million users going through vpn tunnels will produce a unusable experience any way
sometimes you don’t have to ban it, just make the experience crappy enough -
@hardfault Nah, that won't be unusable. It's all a question of smart load balancing, which pretty much all VPN providers are already doing.
-
@PrivateGER may be, but user side experience is crappy based on my uses and none is going to at a paid VPN to use tiktok ( or anything in that regard)
-
@hardfault Eh, I wouldn't be surprised! Most of the audience TikTok has is pretty young, tech proficient and will want to keep using it.
-
@Lensflare there was a LoC violation dispute between Chinese and Indian soldiers
20 indian soldiers died -
Tbh, someone reverse engineered the app and was rather shocked as to what the app collects how it tries to hide this so I'm not remotely surprised
Govt. of India banned Tiktok so well that it is not accessible with a VPN even when you have TikTok installed on your phone.
rant