Ranter
Join devRant
Do all the things like
++ or -- rants, post your own rants, comment on others' rants and build your customized dev avatar
Sign Up
Pipeless API
From the creators of devRant, Pipeless lets you power real-time personalized recommendations and activity feeds using a simple API
Learn More
Comments
-
Isn't color blindness a spectrum? Meaning that everyone will experience it differently. Also, people with color blindness most likely have a different frame of reference, making their expectations and opinions different as well.
-
atheist98503y@ScriptCoded There's different "types" of color blindness, predominantly whether you see red, green or blue (there's some weirdness with purple, but anyway). So it's not really a spectrum.
But to your second point, yes color blind individuals will have a different reference. But then, given people's varying tastes in fashion, don't we all? -
That isn't just an issue for the colorblind.
These icons probably look pretty sameish to full-sighted people too.
They oversimplified their icon set. -
Everybody is clear ... These icon is the worts shit append to google after the google photo is not free anymore
-
Heck?
Icons aren't really about color. That's the reason most icons are actually one color only.. it's about fucking shapes.
These things having multiple colors is just a bonus, if you feel color-offended just use a theme..
Just write "reeee fuck google" like everyone else. -
Hazarth94763yI don't like the new icons either but...
to be completely fair...
the shapes of the icons are completely enough to distinguish them for a colorblind person. So I think this argument doesn't really prove any real points. I dislike the icons from a design perspective, but unless someone colorblind actually has a problem figuring out what the icon is, it's a moot point.
there's an easily recognizable shape as part of each icon.
the M of Gmail, the number inside the calendar, the triangle of Drive, the elongated A4 of Docs and the rectangle of chat
It's objectively worse, but it's not "bad". It does it's job well enough still. I for one never had issue identifying the right icon in my mobile device, but I'm not colorblind... though I also don't use the colors to find them either... it's always the shape that tells me what I'm looking at... -
@nitwhiz I think the problem is that the letter looks less like a letter, the calendar looks less like a calendar, and the document looks less like a document. You can't tell what the app does from the icon. Previously, only Google drive was like this — how does a triangle relate to a storage service?
Accessibility helps all people, not only the weakest.
Here's how Google icons will look from the perspective of a colorblind individual (deuteranopia). See how bad the new icons in the second row looks like.
rant