Ranter
Join devRant
Do all the things like
++ or -- rants, post your own rants, comment on others' rants and build your customized dev avatar
Sign Up
Pipeless API
From the creators of devRant, Pipeless lets you power real-time personalized recommendations and activity feeds using a simple API
Learn More
Comments
-
C0D4669025yMe: explains exactly what needs to occur
Dev: let's do it my way instead
....
Dev: it don't work
Me: explains again
.....
Dev: it don't work
Me: looks at code, that's not what I said
Dev: I know, I'm doing it this way
Me: 🤦♂️what ever
.....
Lead: why is this error occurring?
Me: ask dev, I give up. -
kweusuf115yI had a colleague who was a fan of writing overcomplicated pieces of code. Initially I had no problem with whatever he did... But he left the job and now I have to maintain his code and add features to that shit. I cannot even reengineer it from scratch as it is very rightly coupled with other modules. FML
-
Agred20185yI'm guilty of this in my own projects. I hate duplicating code so I create generic classes instantiated with reflection, hidden behind interfaces and patterns.
I get that it can be frustrating for other devs. Especially inexperienced ones. But as long as it's well documented it shouldn't really be an issue. At least in my case where classes/methods aren't big because of the way I write. In work, leader should make sure not to throw an newbie to work with a code like that and it shouldn't be an issue either. -
dr-ant13445yOver engineering is certainly a problem but if a well designed, complicated piece of code works, it's the developer's responsibility to make it approachable & understandable. Good names, test cases, comments, documentation, whatever it takes. That's where the review process comes in. If someone else gets assigned to it, it's that developer's responsibility to understand it and improve it.
The requirements analysis should keep over engineering in check.
Related Rants
Okay. For fuck sakes, writing complex code that's meant to handle "everything" and is "super generic" can be a fuck up. Like just keep shit simple. THAT is the show of great and impressive work. Over engineering is not it. Yes your shit works and yes your shit is fancy but was it needed? How long did it even take you for this over kill? How long will it take the next person to understand or not.
Someone now has to sit and run through your shit to get what you were doing. Instead of just being able to look and once and have it all figured out.
Keep things simple.
Lost 2 hours on bullshit 🤬
rant
overkill
overengineering
devrant
bullshit
simple
smart